28 May What Is the Difference Between a MAPT and a Revocable Living Trust?
What Is the Difference Between a MAPT and a Revocable Living Trust?
Understanding Two Powerful Estate Planning Tools and When to Use Each
By Martin Fogarty, Founder of ElderSmart
When Illinois families come to my office seeking to protect their assets while planning for potential long-term care needs, I’m often asked about the differences between various trust options. The two most common questions I hear are: “Should I set up a revocable living trust?” and “Do I need a Medicaid Asset Protection Trust?”
These are excellent questions, because both tools serve important but very different purposes in comprehensive estate planning. Understanding the distinction between a Medicaid Asset Protection Trust (MAPT)—like our specialized Elder Protection Trust—and a revocable living trust can mean the difference between losing your life savings to nursing home costs and preserving your legacy for your children.
Over my three decades of practice, I’ve seen countless families assume that any trust would protect them from Medicaid spend-down requirements, only to discover too late that their revocable trust offered no protection whatsoever when long-term care became necessary.
I founded ElderSmart after watching my own father navigate the complex intersection of estate planning and elder care. That experience taught me that choosing the right trust isn’t just about legal technicalities—it’s about understanding your family’s specific goals and the very different protections each type of trust provides.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore:
- The fundamental differences between MAPTs and revocable living trusts
- When each type of trust is most appropriate
- How Illinois law affects both trust types
- The specific benefits and limitations of each approach
- Real-world scenarios showing how families use these tools
- Step-by-step guidance for choosing the right trust for your situation
Understanding Revocable Living Trusts
A revocable living trust is one of the most common estate planning tools, and for good reason. It’s a legal arrangement where you transfer ownership of your assets to a trust while retaining complete control over those assets during your lifetime.
Key Characteristics of Revocable Living Trusts:
Complete Control: As the name suggests, you can revoke, modify, or completely dissolve the trust at any time. You typically serve as both the trustee (manager) and primary beneficiary during your lifetime.
Privacy Protection: Unlike wills, trusts don’t go through public probate proceedings, keeping your family’s financial affairs private.
Incapacity Planning: If you become unable to manage your affairs, your successor trustee can step in seamlessly without court intervention.
Probate Avoidance: Assets in the trust pass directly to beneficiaries without the time, expense, and publicity of probate court.
What Revocable Living Trusts Do Well:
- Provide seamless asset management during incapacity
- Avoid probate delays and costs
- Maintain privacy for your family
- Allow flexible distribution planning for heirs
- Simplify estate administration
- Accommodate changes in family circumstances
What Revocable Living Trusts Don’t Do:
Here’s where many Illinois families get confused: revocable living trusts provide no protection from creditors, lawsuits, or Medicaid spend-down requirements.
Because you retain complete control over the trust assets, they’re still considered your property for all practical purposes. This means:
- Medicaid counts trust assets when determining eligibility
- Creditors can reach trust assets to satisfy claims
- The assets receive no tax advantages during your lifetime
- Nursing home costs can still deplete the entire trust
Understanding Medicaid Asset Protection Trusts (MAPTs)
A Medicaid Asset Protection Trust represents a fundamentally different approach to asset protection.
At ElderSmart, we’ve developed our own specialized version called the Elder Protection Trust, which incorporates decades of experience helping Illinois families navigate Medicaid planning challenges.
Key Characteristics of MAPTs:
Irrevocable Nature: Once established, you cannot revoke the trust or reclaim direct ownership of the assets. This permanence is what provides the protection.
Independent Trustee: You cannot serve as trustee, though you can retain certain limited powers and name family members or trusted advisors as trustees.
Asset Protection: After the five-year Medicaid look-back period, assets are protected from nursing home costs and Medicaid recovery.
Income Retention: Most MAPTs allow you to receive income generated by trust assets for life.
Residence Rights: If your home is transferred to the trust, you typically retain the right to live there for your lifetime.
What MAPTs Do Well:
- Protect assets from Medicaid spend-down after five years
- Shield assets from nursing home costs
- Prevent Medicaid estate recovery
- Preserve family wealth for future generations
- Provide creditor protection
- Maintain some tax advantages
What MAPTs Require:
- Five-year advance planning (due to Medicaid look-back rules)
- Giving up direct control of assets
- Careful selection of trustees
- Understanding of irrevocable commitment
- Professional guidance for proper structuring
Side-by-Side Comparison: MAPT vs. Revocable Living Trust
| Feature | Revocable Living Trust | MAPT / Elder Protection Trust |
| Control | Complete control retained | Limited control given up |
| Flexibility | Can be changed anytime | Irrevocable once established |
| Medicaid Protection | None | Full protection after 5 years |
| Creditor Protection | None | Strong Protection |
| Probate Avoidance | Yes | Yes |
| Privacy | Yes | Yes |
| Income Rights | Complete | Usually retained |
| Planning Timeline | Immediate benefits | 5-year planning required |
| Complexity | Moderate | High Complexity |
| Cost | Low initial cost | Higher but comprehensive |
When to Choose a Revocable Living Trust
Revocable living trusts work best for families whose primary concerns are:
Estate Planning Without Medicaid Concerns:
If you have sufficient resources to privately pay for long-term care, or comprehensive long-term care insurance, a revocable trust may meet your needs perfectly.
Consider the Johnsons from Naperville: Both retired teachers with pensions, Social Security, and $800,000 in savings. They’re primarily concerned with avoiding probate and providing for their children if both parents pass away. Since they can afford private-pay care and aren’t concerned about Medicaid eligibility, a revocable living trust handles their estate planning goals effectively.
Younger Families:
Families in their 40s and 50s with growing wealth often benefit from revocable trusts for basic estate planning, then can layer on asset protection strategies like MAPTs later as they approach traditional long-term care ages.
Flexibility Priorities:
If you need the ability to readily access and restructure your assets, a revocable trust provides that flexibility while still offering basic estate planning benefits.
When to Choose a MAPT (Elder Protection Trust)
Our Elder Protection Trust and other MAPTs are most appropriate when:
Long-Term Care Protection is Priority:
If preserving assets from nursing home costs is a primary concern, only an irrevocable trust like our Elder Protection Trust provides this protection.
Consider the Millers from Rockford: Tom, 68, and Susan, 66, have $600,000 in retirement assets and own their home worth $350,000. Tom’s father spent three years in a nursing facility, depleting the family’s savings. The Millers want to ensure their assets pass to their children regardless of future care needs. An Elder Protection Trust allows them to protect these assets while retaining income rights and the right to live in their home.
Blended Family Situations:
When spouses have children from previous marriages, MAPTs can ensure assets go to intended beneficiaries rather than being depleted by care costs.
Significant Assets with Medicaid Concerns:
Families with substantial assets who still want Medicaid protection often benefit from splitting strategies—some assets in revocable trusts for flexibility, others in MAPTs for protection.
Generational Wealth Transfer:
When preserving family wealth across generations is important, MAPTs provide both protection and tax advantages.
Common Illinois Family Scenarios
Let me walk you through scenarios that illustrate when each trust type works best:
Scenario 1: The Suburban Empty Nesters
The Situation: Bob and Mary from Schaumburg, both 62, have $1.2 million in retirement accounts, own their $450,000 home free and clear, and are healthy with no family history of extended care needs.
Primary Concerns: Avoiding probate, providing for the surviving spouse, and eventually passing assets to their three adult children.
ElderSmart’s Recommendation: A well-designed revocable living trust meets their immediate needs. They can always add asset protection strategies later if circumstances change or if they decide long-term care protection becomes a priority.
Scenario 2: The Planning-Ahead Couple
The Situation: Jim and Linda from Peoria, both 58, have witnessed both sets of parents go through extended nursing home stays. They have $800,000 in combined assets and want to ensure something passes to their children.
Primary Concerns: Protecting assets from potential nursing home costs while maintaining some flexibility and income.
ElderSmart’s Recommendation: Our Elder Protection Trust allows them to protect a significant portion of their assets while they’re healthy and more than five years away from likely care needs. They might combine this with a smaller revocable trust for assets they want to keep flexible.
Scenario 3: The Blended Family
The Situation: Frank, 65, and Carol, 63, each have adult children from previous marriages. Frank has $500,000 in assets he wants to ensure go to his children, while Carol has $400,000 she wants protected for her children.
Primary Concerns: Ensuring assets go to intended beneficiaries while protecting from care costs and potential family conflicts.
ElderSmart’s Recommendation: Separate Elder Protection Trusts for each spouse’s assets, ensuring both Medicaid protection and clear beneficiary designation that can’t be changed by the surviving spouse.
Scenario 4: The Late Planners
The Situation: Robert, 72, and Patricia, 70, from Springfield have $650,000 in assets and are just beginning to think about long-term planning. Robert has early signs of cognitive decline.
Primary Concerns: Immediate estate planning needs with some asset protection if possible.
ElderSmart’s Recommendation: A revocable living trust for immediate incapacity planning and probate avoidance, potentially combined with other Medicaid planning strategies that don’t require the five-year waiting period.
The ElderSmart Elder Protection Trust
At ElderSmart, we’ve developed our Elder Protection Trust specifically for Illinois families who need comprehensive asset protection combined with practical benefits. Here’s what makes our approach different:
Customized for Illinois Law:
Our Elder Protection Trust is designed specifically to work within Illinois Medicaid rules and estate laws, ensuring maximum protection and compliance.
Income Retention Features:
Unlike some MAPTs, our Elder Protection Trust typically allows you to retain income rights, providing financial security during your lifetime.
Flexible Trustee Options:
We help families select appropriate trustees and can provide ongoing support to ensure proper trust administration.
Comprehensive Planning Integration:
The Elder Protection Trust works as part of a complete planning strategy that may include revocable trusts, powers of attorney, healthcare directives, and other tools.
Ongoing Support:
ElderSmart provides continued guidance to ensure your trust remains effective and compliant as laws and circumstances change.
Can You Have Both Types of Trusts?
Absolutely! Many Illinois families benefit from using both revocable living trusts and MAPTs as part of a comprehensive strategy.
Common Combination Strategies:
Split Asset Approach: Place assets you want to keep flexible (like emergency funds) in a revocable trust, while protecting long-term assets (like the family home) in a MAPT.
Timing Strategy: Use a revocable trust for immediate estate planning benefits, then later transfer some assets to a MAPT when you’re ready for the five-year commitment.
Spousal Strategy: One spouse uses a revocable trust for flexibility, while the other spouse’s assets go into a MAPT for protection.
Generational Strategy: Current generation uses revocable trusts for flexibility, while setting up MAPTs to protect assets for children and grandchildren.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
With Revocable Living Trusts:
- Assuming they provide Medicaid protection
- Forgetting to fund the trust with assets
- Not updating beneficiary designations
- Failing to coordinate with other estate planning documents
With MAPTs:
- Setting up too late (within five years of needing care)
- Not understanding the irrevocable nature
- Poor trustee selection
- Insufficient income planning
- Not coordinating with overall financial plan
Making the Right Trust Choice for Your Family
Choosing between a MAPT and a revocable living trust, or determining if you need both, depends on several factors:
Key Questions to Consider:
- What are your primary planning goals? (Probate avoidance vs. asset protection)
- How important is maintaining control vs. gaining protection?
- What’s your timeline? (Immediate needs vs. five-year planning horizon)
- What are your family dynamics? (Simple vs. complex beneficiary situations)
- What’s your risk tolerance for long-term care costs?
- How do your assets compare to potential care costs?
The ElderSmart Evaluation Process:
At ElderSmart, we don’t believe in one-size-fits-all solutions. Our process includes:
Comprehensive Asset Review: Understanding your complete financial picture and family goals.
Risk Assessment: Evaluating your potential long-term care exposure and family health history.
Goal Clarification: Helping you prioritize competing objectives like flexibility vs. protection.
Strategy Development: Creating a customized plan that may include one or both trust types.
Implementation Support: Ensuring proper setup and ongoing compliance.
Regular Reviews: Adapting your plan as circumstances and laws change.
The Bottom Line: Protection vs. Flexibility
The fundamental difference between MAPTs and revocable living trusts comes down to a trade-off between protection and flexibility:
Revocable Living Trusts offer maximum flexibility and control but provide no asset protection from creditors, lawsuits, or Medicaid spend-down requirements.
MAPTs (including our Elder Protection Trust) require giving up some control and flexibility but provide powerful protection from nursing home costs and other creditors after the five-year waiting period.
Many Illinois families find that the optimal approach uses both tools strategically, providing flexibility where needed and protection where it matters most.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I convert my revocable trust to a MAPT later?
Not exactly “convert,” but you can transfer assets from a revocable trust to a MAPT. However, this starts the five-year clock for Medicaid protection.
Which trust is better for avoiding probate?
Both avoid probate equally well, assuming they’re properly funded with your assets.
Can I be the trustee of my own MAPT?
No, you cannot serve as trustee of your own MAPT, as this would defeat the asset protection benefits. However, you can retain certain limited powers and influence over trust decisions.
Do I need an attorney for both types of trusts?
Yes, both require proper legal drafting. MAPTs especially require specialized expertise in elder law and Medicaid planning.
Can I fund both trusts with the same assets?
No, specific assets go into one trust or the other. However, you can have different assets in different trusts as part of an overall strategy.
What happens if I need to access MAPT assets in an emergency?
This depends on how the trust is structured. Some provisions allow for distributions in limited circumstances, but accessing assets generally undermines the protection.
Moving Forward: Your Next Steps
Understanding the differences between MAPTs and revocable living trusts is just the beginning. The most important step is evaluating which approach—or combination of approaches—best serves your family’s unique needs and goals.
Whether you’re focused on basic estate planning or comprehensive asset protection, the key is getting started with proper professional guidance. The wrong choice can be costly, but the right strategy can provide peace of mind and financial security for your family.
At ElderSmart, we’ve spent over three decades helping Illinois families navigate these important decisions. We understand that every family’s situation is different, and we take pride in developing customized solutions that address your specific concerns while working within Illinois law.
Most importantly, we recognize that behind every trust decision is a family trying to protect what they’ve worked their entire lives to build while ensuring their loved ones are cared for properly.
Don’t leave your family’s financial security to chance. Whether you need the flexibility of a revocable trust, the protection of our Elder Protection Trust, or a combination strategy, proper planning makes all the difference.
Contact ElderSmart today for a confidential consultation. Let’s review your situation and develop a trust strategy that provides the right balance of protection and flexibility for your family’s needs.
Learn more about our Elder Protection Trust
Martin Fogarty is the founder of ElderSmart and has spent over three decades guiding Illinois families through complex estate planning and elder care decisions. His approach combines deep legal expertise with genuine compassion, earned through both professional experience and his family’s personal journey through long-term care challenges.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for general educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. ElderSmart.net makes no representations or warranties as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability of this information for any purpose. You should consult a qualified attorney regarding your specific legal situation.
Use of this website or communication with ElderSmart does not create an attorney-client relationship. Do not send confidential or sensitive information until such a relationship has been formally established.
By using this site, you acknowledge and agree that ElderSmart.net is not liable for any losses, injuries, or damages arising from your reliance on the content provided. For more details, please review our full Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.